Blog
Published
Steady-State Solver and Multiple Reference Frame Approach
Julian Toumey
Author: Julian Toumey
Senior Research Engineer

One of CONVERGE's strengths has always been providing accurate results for complex transient problems with moving geometry. With the introduction of new features in CONVERGE v2.4, this strength extends to steady-state problems.

Two new features in CONVERGE v2.4 that accelerate your steady-state simulations are the completely redesigned steady-state solver and the new multiple reference frame (MRF) approach. These new features work particularly well together when applied to problems with moving geometry but for which you expect a steady-state result. Some examples of such problems are dynamic compressors, fans, and pumps.

The new steady-state solver in CONVERGE v2.4 leverages the steady-state monitor to track the convergence of flow quantities. The simulation begins with an automatically coarsened grid and loose solution tolerances for the governing equations, which allows fluid flow to rapidly propagate through the domain. CONVERGE progressively refines the grid and tightens solution tolerances to improve the solution accuracy as each monitored flow variable falls within a specified mean and standard deviation.

For simulations of devices with moving geometry (e.g., compressors/fans/pumps), the MRF approach reduces computational time with a very small impact on accuracy. The crux of this approach is to treat the moving portion of the geometry (e.g., the impeller for a pump) as a separate reference frame. CONVERGE transforms the flow quantities from the inertial frame to the moving frame to represent the geometry movement.

Figure 1. The fan geometry.

The centrifugal fan example case below compares several approaches to accelerating simulations in which we expect a steady-state result. This case is the ERCOFTAC centrifugal fan with vaned diffuser (Figure 1 below shows the fan geometry). The results shown below in Figures 2 and 3 compare mass flow rate at the outlet for three cases: steady-state solver with the MRF approach, transient solver with the MRF approach, and transient solver with moving geometry.

For mass flow initial conditions, the two MRF cases use a uniform value throughout the entire domain. The moving geometry case, however, employs a more accurate initial condition obtained from prior simulations on a coarse grid. Despite this more accurate initial condition, the moving geometry case takes several thousand more cycles to converge to an accurate steady-state.

Note that the two cases that employ the new v2.4 MRF approach converge much faster than the case that includes moving geometry. Furthermore, the case that uses the MRF approach and the steady-state solver converges the fastest of the three cases, and it takes fewer than 1,000 cycles. Figure 4 below compares the wall clock times for these solver configurations.

All three cases are within 3% of experimental results for mass flow rate and pressure rise.

Figure 2. Outlet mass flow rate convergence history.

When the simulation will yield a steady-state result, the MRF approach combined with the steady-state solver in CONVERGE v2.4 will rapidly obtain accurate results.

Figure 3. Outlet mass flow rate convergence history, zoomed.

Figure 4. Comparison of wall clock time for various solver approaches.

Contact Us Today
Learn more about how CONVERGE helps you quickly and accurately solve your CFD problems.

Would you like to receive periodic emails from Convergent Science about the latest CONVERGE news, announcements, training opportunities, and events?
You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us at [email protected].
There has been a problem submitting your information.
Thank you for contacting us!
To complete the process of joining our mailing list please navigate to the link in the email we just sent you. This will confirm your email address.
We will be in touch as soon as possible.

Mailing List Signup

Sign up for our mailing list and stay up to date on the latest CONVERGE news, announcements, and events.
You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us at [email protected].
Thank you for signing up!
To complete the process of joining our mailing list please navigate to the link in the email we just sent you. This will confirm your email address.

Access Resource

Please fill out the information below to access this resource.
There has been a problem submitting your information.
Thank you for submitting your information.
Download Resource
Access Resource